You might think that the debacle in Iraq would be enough
for the Pentagon, that it would not be in the mood to seek
out new routes to unnecessary wars for the United States to
fight. But with Donald Rumsfeld at the apex of the defense
establishment, enough is never enough.
So, as detailed in an article in The Times on Dec. 19,
Mr. Rumsfeld's minions are concocting yet another grandiose
and potentially disastrous scheme. Pentagon officials are
putting together a plan that would give the military a more
prominent role in intelligence gathering operations that
traditionally have been handled by the Central Intelligence
Agency. They envision the military doing more spying with
humans, as opposed, for example, to surveillance with
satellites.
Further encroachment by the military into intelligence
matters better handled by civilians is bad enough. Now hold
your breath. According to the article, "Among the ideas
cited by Defense Department officials is the idea of
'fighting for intelligence,' or commencing combat operations
chiefly to obtain intelligence."
That is utter madness. The geniuses in Washington have
already launched one bogus war, which has cost tens of
thousands of lives and provoked levels of suffering that are
impossible to quantify. We don't need to be contemplating
new forms of warfare waged for the sole purpose of gathering
intelligence.
Part of this plan to further aggrandize Mr. Rumsfeld is
being drafted under the direction of Lt. Gen. William
Boykin, a deputy under secretary of defense who has already
demonstrated that he should not be allowed anywhere near the
most serious matters of national security. General Boykin,
who once had the job of directing the hunt for Osama bin
Laden, is an evangelical Christian who believes God put
President Bush in the White House. He has described the
fight against Islamic militants as a struggle against Satan
and declared that it can be won only "if we come at them in
the name of Jesus."
General Boykin asserted his views in speeches that he
delivered in his military uniform at religious functions
around the country. In one speech, referring to a Muslim
fighter in Somalia, the general said: "Well, you know what I
knew - that my God was bigger than his. I knew that my God
was a real God, and his was an idol."
General Boykin was forced to apologize after media
accounts led to widespread criticism. But the Bush
administration is still holding him tightly in its embrace.
How difficult is it to come to the conclusion that this is
not a fellow who should be making decisions on matters
involving armed conflict with Muslims?
It's also time to rein in Mr. Rumsfeld. As The Times
noted in a recent editorial, "The last time Mr. Rumsfeld
tried to force himself into the intelligence collection and
analysis business, he created a boutique C.I.A. in the
bowels of the Pentagon under the command of Douglas Feith,
the under secretary of defense for policy. The office
essentially fabricated a link between Saddam Hussein and
Osama bin Laden - a link used to justify the Iraq invasion,
and one that Mr. Rumsfeld was not getting from the C.I.A."
As Mr. Rumsfeld sees it, if the professionals won't give
you what you want, find someone who will. What the Bush
administration wanted from its intelligence sources was a
reason to go to war. Mr. Rumsfeld's shop was more than happy
to oblige.
The war in Iraq was the result of powerful government
figures imposing their dangerous fantasies on the world. The
fantasies notably included the weapons of mass destruction,
the links between Al Qaeda and Saddam Hussein, the throngs
of Iraqis hurling kisses and garlands at the invading
Americans, and the spread of American-style democracy
throughout the Middle East. All voices of caution were
ignored and the fantasies were allowed to prevail.
The world is not a video game, although it must seem like
it at times to the hubristic, hermetically sealed
powerbrokers in Washington who manipulate the forces that
affect the lives of so many millions of people in every
region of the planet. That kind of power calls for humility,
not arrogance, and should be wielded wisely, not
thoughtlessly and impulsively.
This latest overreach by Mr. Rumsfeld is a sign that the
administration, like a hardheaded adolescent, has learned
little or nothing from the tragic consequences of its
wrongheaded policies. The second term is coming, so buckle
up. It promises to be a very dangerous four years.
E-mail: bobherb@nytimes.com