WASHINGTON, Jan. 17 - A high-level intelligence
assessment by the Bush administration concluded in early
2002 that the sale of uranium from
Niger to
Iraq was "unlikely" because of a host of economic,
diplomatic and logistical obstacles, according to a secret
memo that was recently declassified by the State Department.
Among other problems that made such a sale improbable,
the assessment by the State Department's intelligence
analysts concluded, was that it would have required Niger to
send "25 hard-to-conceal 10-ton tractor-trailers" filled
with uranium across 1,000 miles and at least one
international border.
The analysts' doubts were registered nearly a year before
President Bush, in what became known as the infamous "16
words" in his 2003 State of the Union address, said that
Saddam Hussein had sought significant quantities of
uranium from Africa.
The White House later acknowledged that the charge, which
played a part in the decision to invade Iraq in the belief
that Baghdad was reconstituting its nuclear program, relied
on faulty intelligence and should not have been included in
the speech. Two months ago, Italian intelligence officials
concluded that a set of documents at the center of the
supposed Iraq-Niger link had been forged by an occasional
Italian spy.
A handful of news reports, along with the Robb-Silberman
report last year on intelligence failures in Iraq, have
previously made reference to the early doubts expressed by
the State Department's bureau of intelligence and research
in 2002 concerning the reliability of the Iraq-Niger uranium
link.
But the intelligence assessment itself - including the
analysts' full arguments in raising wide-ranging doubts
about the credence of the uranium claim - was only recently
declassified as part of a Freedom of Information Act lawsuit
brought by Judicial Watch, a conservative legal group that
has sought access to government documents on terrorism and
intelligence matters. The group, which received a copy of
the 2002 memo among several hundred pages of other
documents, provided a copy of the memo to The New York
Times.
The White House declined to discuss details of the
declassified memo, saying the Niger question had already
been explored at length since the president's State of the
Union address.
"This matter was examined fully by the bipartisan
Silberman-Robb commission, and the president acted on their
broad recommendations to reform our intelligence apparatus,"
said Frederick Jones, a spokesman for the National Security
Council.
The public release of the State Department assessment,
with some sections blacked out, adds another level of detail
to an episode that was central not only to the debate over
the invasion of Iraq, but also in the perjury indictment of
I.
Lewis Libby Jr., the former chief of staff to Vice
President
Dick Cheney.
In early 2002, the Central Intelligence Agency sent the
former ambassador
Joseph C. Wilson IV to Niger to investigate possible
attempts to sell uranium to Iraq. The next year, after Mr.
Wilson became a vocal critic of the Bush administration's
Iraqi intelligence, the identity of his wife, Valerie
Wilson, a C.I.A. officer who suggested him for the Niger
trip, was made public. The investigation into the leak led
to criminal charges in October against Mr. Libby, who is
accused of misleading investigators and a grand jury.
The review by the State Department's intelligence bureau
was one of a number of reviews undertaken in early 2002 at
the State Department in response to secret intelligence
pointing to the possibility that Iraq was seeking to buy
yellowcake, a processed uranium ore, from Niger to
reconstitute its nuclear program.
A four-star general, Carlton W. Fulford Jr., was also
sent to Niger to investigate the claims of a uranium
purchase. He, too, came away with doubts about the
reliability of the report and believed Niger's yellowcake
supply to be secure. But the State Department's review,
which looked at the political, economic and logistical
factors in such a purchase, seems to have produced
wider-ranging doubts than other reviews about the likelihood
that Niger would try to sell uranium to Baghdad.
The review concluded that Niger was "probably not
planning to sell uranium to Iraq," in part because France
controlled the uranium industry in the country and could
block such a sale. It also cast doubt on an intelligence
report indicating that Niger's president, Mamadou Tandja,
might have negotiated a sales agreement with Iraq in 2000.
Mr. Tandja and his government were reluctant to do anything
to endanger their foreign aid from the United States and
other allies, the review concluded. The State Department
review also cast doubt on the logistics of Niger being able
to deliver 500 tons of uranium even if the sale were
attempted. "Moving such a quantity secretly over such a
distance would be very difficult, particularly because the
French would be indisposed to approve or cloak this
arrangement," the review said.
Chris Farrell, the director of investigations at Judicial
Watch and a former military intelligence officer, said he
found the State Department's analysis to be "a very strong,
well-thought-out argument that looks at the whole playing
field in Niger, and it makes a compelling case for why the
uranium sale was so unlikely."
The memo, dated March 4, 2002, was distributed at senior
levels by the office of Secretary of State
Colin L. Powell and by the Defense Intelligence Agency.
A Bush administration official, who requested anonymity
because the issue involved partly classified documents,
would not say whether President Bush had seen the State
Department's memo before his State of the Union address on
Jan. 28, 2003.
But the official added: "The White House is not an
intelligence-gathering operation. The president based his
remarks in the State of the Union address on the
intelligence that was presented to him by the intelligence
community and cleared by the intelligence community. The
president has said the intelligence was wrong, and we have
reorganized our intelligence agencies so we can do better in
the future."
Mr. Wilson said in an interview that he did not remember
ever seeing the memo but that its analysis should raise
further questions about why the White House remained
convinced for so long that Iraq was trying to buy uranium in
Africa.
"All the people understood that there was documentary
evidence" suggesting that the intelligence about the sale
was faulty, he said.